Sincerely,
|
|
William H. Cunningham
|
|
Chairman of the Board
|
May 21, 2015
|
9:00 a.m. local time
|
The Ritz-Carlton Hotel
10 Avenue of the Arts
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19102
|
|
1.
|
elect four directors for a one-year term expiring at the 2016 Annual Meeting;
|
|
2.
|
ratify the appointment of Ernst & Young LLP as our independent registered public accounting firm for 2015;
|
|
3.
|
approve an advisory resolution on the compensation of our named executive officers; and
|
|
4.
|
consider and vote upon any other matters that might come up at the meeting.
|
SIGNING AND RETURNING
A PROXY CARD
|
TOLL-FREE TELEPHONE
|
THE INTERNET
|
IN PERSON AT
THE ANNUAL MEETING
|
PROXY SUMMARY
|
1
|
GOVERNANCE OF THE COMPANY
|
3
|
AGENDA ITEM 1 - ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
12
|
Phase-Out of Classified Board
|
12
|
Nominees for Director
|
13
|
DIRECTORS CONTINUING IN OFFICE
|
15
|
COMPENSATION OF OUTSIDE DIRECTORS
|
19
|
AGENDA ITEM 2 - RATIFICATION OF APPOINTMENT OF INDEPENDENT
REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM
|
23
|
Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm Fees and Services
|
23
|
Audit Committee Pre-Approval Policy
|
24
|
Other Information
|
24
|
Audit Committee Report
|
25
|
AGENDA ITEM 3 - ADVISORY PROPOSAL ON EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION
|
26
|
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
|
28
|
Executive Summary
|
29
|
Compensation Committee Report
|
54
|
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION TABLES
|
55
|
Summary Compensation Table
|
55
|
Grants of Plan-Based Awards
|
58
|
Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year-End
|
60
|
Option Exercises and Stock Vested
|
62
|
Pension Benefits
|
62
|
Nonqualified Deferred Compensation
|
64
|
Potential Payments Upon Termination or Change of Control
|
66
|
COMPENSATION COMMITTEE INTERLOCKS AND INSIDER PARTICIPATION
|
73
|
RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
|
73
|
SECURITY OWNERSHIP
|
74
|
ANNUAL MEETING INFORMATION
|
76
|
GENERAL INFORMATION
|
80
|
Shareholder Proposals
|
80
|
Incorporation by Reference
|
81
|
Compliance with Beneficial Ownership Reporting
|
81
|
Annual Report
|
81
|
Additional Voting Matters
|
81
|
EXHIBIT 1 – Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Measures
|
E-1
|
EXHIBIT 2 – List of Investment Management Companies from the 2013 McLagan Survey and Financial Services Companies from the 2013 Towers Watson Survey
|
E-4
|
EXHIBIT 3 – List of Investment Companies from the 2013 McLagan Survey
|
E-6
|
EXHIBIT 4 – Definitions for Incentive Compensation Programs
|
E-7
|
DATE/TIME
Thursday, May 21, 2015
9:00 a.m. local time
|
PLACE
The Ritz-Carlton Hotel
10 Avenue of the Arts
Philadelphia, PA 19102
RECORD DATE
March 16, 2015
|
VOTING
Shareholders as of the record date are entitled to vote. Each share of common stock is entitled to one vote for each director nominee and one vote for each of the other proposals.
|
AGENDA ITEM
|
OUR BOARD’S VOTING RECOMMENDATION
|
WHERE TO FIND MORE INFORMATION
|
|||
1.
|
Election of four directors for a one-year term expiring at the 2016 Annual Meeting.
|
FOR each director nominee
|
Page 12
|
||
2.
|
Ratification of Ernst & Young LLP as our independent registered public accounting firm for 2015.
|
FOR the ratification
|
Page 23
|
||
3.
|
Approval of advisory resolution on the compensation of our named executive officers.
|
FOR the resolution
|
Page 26
|
NAME
|
AGE
|
DIRECTOR
SINCE
|
OCCUPATION
|
INDEPENDENT
|
COMMITTEE
MEMBERSHIPS
|
George W. Henderson, III
|
66
|
2006
|
Retired Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Burlington Industries, Inc.
|
Yes
|
Audit
Finance
|
Eric G. Johnson
|
64
|
1998
|
President and Chief Executive Officer, Baldwin Richardson Foods Company
|
Yes
|
Compensation
Executive
Finance
|
M. Leanne Lachman
|
72
|
1985
|
President, Lachman Associates LLC and Executive in Residence, Columbia Graduate School of Business
|
Yes
|
Audit
|
Isaiah Tidwell
|
70
|
2006
|
Retired Executive Vice President and Georgia Wealth Management Director, Wachovia Bank, N.A.
|
Yes
|
Audit
Corporate
Governance
|
·
|
The Chairman of the Board is an independent director;
|
·
|
All of our directors, except for the chief executive officer, are independent;
|
·
|
We have majority voting and a director resignation policy for directors in uncontested elections;
|
·
|
We have robust stock ownership guidelines for directors and executive officers;
|
·
|
Independent directors meet regularly in executive session;
|
·
|
The Board and its committees conduct annual self-evaluations; and
|
·
|
Beginning in 2017, we will no longer have a classified Board and all directors will stand for election annually.
|
MOTIVATE OUR EXECUTIVES TO INCREASE
PROFITABILITY AND SHAREHOLDER RETURN
|
PAY COMPENSATION THAT VARIES
BASED ON PERFORMANCE
|
RETAIN KEY EXECUTIVE TALENT,
AS THIS IS CRITICAL TO OUR SUCCESS
|
·
|
achieving specific annual and long-term strategic and financial goals; and
|
·
|
increasing shareholder value.
|
BOARD AND COMMITTEES: AREAS OF RISK OVERSIGHT
|
||||||
FULL BOARD
|
AUDIT
|
COMPENSATION
|
FINANCE
|
|||
· Strategy
· Operations
· Competition
· Financial strategies and transactions
|
· Company’s enterprise risk management
efforts
· Financial statements
· Financial reporting process
· Accounting and audit matters
· Legal, compliance and regulatory matters
|
· Compensation policies and practices
· Executive incentive compensation and
stock ownership
· Executive retention and succession
planning
|
· Investment policies, strategies and
guidelines
· Capital management and structure
· Financial plan
|
|||
·
|
A majority of our Board must at all times be "independent" as defined by Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) rules and New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”) listing standards.
|
·
|
Our independent directors must meet in executive session at least once a year, with no members of management present. Our outside directors, all of whom are independent, meet in connection with each regularly scheduled Board meeting and at any other times they may choose.
|
·
|
Only independent directors may serve on the Audit, Compensation and Corporate Governance committees.
|
·
|
The written charters of the Audit, Compensation, and Corporate Governance committees comply with the NYSE’s listing standards and are reviewed at least once each year.
|
·
|
We have a Code of Conduct, available on our website at www.lfg.com that includes our "code of ethics" for purposes of SEC rules and our “code of business conduct and ethics” for purposes of the NYSE listing standards. We will disclose amendments to or waivers from a required provision of the code by including such information on our website.
|
·
|
Directors may not stand for election or reelection after reaching age 75.
|
·
|
directors Avery, Cunningham, Henderson, Johnson, Kelly, Lachman, Mee, Payne, Pittard and Tidwell are independent; and
|
·
|
all members of the Audit, Compensation and Corporate Governance committees are independent of our management and of the Company.
|
CURRENT COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP AND MEETINGS HELD DURING 2014 (C=CHAIR M=MEMBER)
|
||||||
NAME
|
AUDIT
|
COMPENSATION
|
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
|
EXECUTIVE
|
FINANCE
|
CORPORATE ACTION 1
|
William J. Avery
|
M
|
M
|
||||
William H. Cunningham
|
M
|
M
|
C
|
M
|
||
Dennis R. Glass
|
M
|
C
|
||||
George W. Henderson, III
|
M
|
M
|
||||
Eric G. Johnson
|
M
|
M
|
C
|
|||
Gary C. Kelly
|
M
|
M
|
||||
M. Leanne Lachman
|
C
|
|||||
Michael F. Mee
|
M
|
M
|
M
|
|||
William P. Payne
|
C
|
M
|
||||
Patrick S. Pittard
|
C
|
|||||
Isaiah Tidwell
|
M
|
M
|
||||
Number of Meetings in 2014:
|
8
|
4
|
4
|
0
|
4
|
--
|
AUDIT COMMITTEE
The primary function of the Audit Committee is oversight, including risk oversight. This includes:
|
|
•
|
helping the Board oversee: (1) the integrity of our financial statements; (2) our compliance with legal and regulatory requirements; (3) the independent auditor’s qualifications and independence; (4) the performance of our general auditor and independent auditor; and (5) our risk assessment and risk management policies and processes
|
•
|
hiring, firing and overseeing the independent auditors and approving their compensation and all of their engagements
|
•
|
assessing significant matters arising from any audit
|
•
|
discussing our annual and quarterly consolidated financial statements and “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations” included in our SEC filings and annual report to shareholders
|
•
|
inquiring about significant risks and exposures, if any, and reviewing and assessing the steps taken to monitor and manage them
|
•
|
reviewing and discussing the risk policies and procedures adopted by management and the implementation of these policies
|
•
|
reviewing the qualifications and backgrounds of senior risk officers
|
•
|
establishing procedures for handling complaints regarding accounting, internal auditing controls or auditing matters and for the confidential, anonymous submission of employee concerns regarding questionable accounting or auditing matters
|
•
|
consulting with management before the appointment or replacement of the internal auditor
|
•
|
preparing the report required for inclusion in our annual proxy statement
|
•
|
reporting the Committee’s activities to the Board on a regular basis and making any recommendations the Committee deems appropriate.
|
The Board has determined that Gary C. Kelly is an “audit committee financial expert” as defined under SEC rules. The Audit Committee may obtain advice and assistance from internal or external legal, accounting or other advisers.
|
|
More information regarding the Audit Committee, including the Audit Committee Report, can be found under “Ratification of Appointment of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm” beginning on page 23.
|
COMPENSATION COMMITTEE
The principal functions of the Compensation Committee include:
|
|
•
|
establishing our general compensation philosophy, in consultation with the compensation consultant and senior management
|
•
|
ensuring that succession plans are in place for the CEO and other executive officers
|
•
|
reviewing and approving corporate goals and objectives for NEO compensation
|
•
|
evaluating the CEO’s performance, and setting the CEO’s compensation level based on this evaluation
|
•
|
evaluating annually whether the Company’s compensation programs create unnecessary risks that could harm the Company
|
•
|
reviewing with management the Compensation Discussion & Analysis to be included in the proxy statement
|
•
|
reviewing and approving all strategies, policies and programs related to the compensation of our executive officers and other key personnel
|
•
|
making recommendations to the Board regarding incentive compensation and equity-based plans and approving all grants and awards to executive officers under such plans
|
•
|
approving employment and severance agreements for executive officers
|
•
|
approving certain employee benefit and executive compensation plans and programs and changes to such plans and programs
|
•
|
reporting the Committee’s activities to the Board on a regular basis and making any recommendations to the Board that the Committee deems appropriate.
|
The Compensation Committee may retain or obtain advice on executive compensation-related matters from a compensation consultant, outside legal counsel or other adviser. The Committee is directly responsible for appointing, compensating and overseeing the work of any such advisers and must consider certain independence factors before hiring them. More information concerning the Compensation Committee, including the role of its compensation consultant and our executive officers in determining or recommending the amount or form of executive compensation, can be found in the “Compensation Discussion & Analysis” section beginning on page 28.
|
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE COMMITTEE
The principal functions of the Corporate Governance Committee include:
|
|
•
|
identifying individuals qualified to become Board members
|
•
|
recommending to the Board nominees for director (including those recommended by shareholders in accordance with our Bylaws)
|
•
|
taking a leadership role in shaping our corporate governance and recommending to the Board the corporate governance principles applicable to us
|
•
|
developing and recommending to the Board standards for determining the independence of directors
|
•
|
making recommendations to the Board regarding the compensation program for directors
|
•
|
making recommendations to the Board regarding the size of the Board and the membership, size, structure and function of its committees
|
•
|
helping evaluate the Board and individual directors
|
•
|
reporting the Committee’s activities to the Board on a regular basis and making any recommendations the Committee deems appropriate.
|
The Corporate Governance Committee may hire and terminate search firms; approve any search firm’s fees and terms of retention; and seek advice and assistance from internal or external legal, accounting or other advisers.
|
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
The principal function of the Executive Committee is to act for the Board, when necessary, between Board meetings. In such instances, the Executive Committee may act for the Board in managing and directing the Company's business and affairs, except for matters expressly delegated to another committee or the full Board. The Executive Committee reports any actions it takes to the Board as soon as practicable.
|
FINANCE COMMITTEE
The principal functions of the Finance Committee include:
|
||
•
|
reviewing and providing guidance to senior management with respect to:
|
|
‒
|
our annual three-year financial plan;
|
|
‒
|
our capital structure, including issuance of securities by us or any of our affiliates, significant “off balance sheet” transactions, and our dividend and share repurchase strategies;
|
|
‒
|
our reinsurance strategies; and
|
|
‒
|
proposed mergers, acquisitions, divestitures, joint ventures and other strategic investments
|
|
•
|
reviewing our overall credit quality and credit ratings strategy
|
|
•
|
reviewing the general account and our investment policies, strategies and guidelines
|
|
•
|
reviewing our hedging program and the policies and procedures governing the use of financial instruments, including derivatives
|
|
•
|
reviewing the funding adequacy of our qualified pension plans, including significant actuarial assumptions, investment policies and performance
|
|
•
|
reporting the Committee’s activities to the Board on a regular basis and making any recommendations the Committee deems appropriate.
|
|
The Finance Committee may seek advice and assistance from internal or external legal, accounting or other advisers.
|
COMMITTEE ON CORPORATE ACTION
|
|
The Committee on Corporate Action was formed to delegate to the sole member, the CEO, the authority to take certain actions on behalf of the Board in accordance with limits set by the Board. The principal functions that have been delegated to the Committee on Corporate Action include:
|
|
•
|
determining the pricing of the securities offered from our shelf registration statement, including all rates, payments, ratios, discounts and other financial measures related to the pricing of such securities;
|
•
|
approving, as necessary, the underwriting agreement, form of security and other transaction documents relating to the offering and sale of securities under our shelf registration statement; and
|
•
|
appointing and removing certain classes of our officers as the Board may determine by resolution.
|
GEORGE W. HENDERSON, III
RETIRED CHAIRMAN AND CHIEF
EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF
BURLINGTON INDUSTRIES, INC.
|
AGE: 66 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2006
Member, Audit and Finance committees
Mr. Henderson also serves as a director of Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York, one of our insurance subsidiaries.
|
||
CAREER
|
Mr. Henderson was Chairman and CEO of Burlington Industries, a global manufacturer of textile products, from 1998–2003. Before that he served as that company’s President and its COO. He was also a member of Burlington’s Board of Directors for 13 years.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Executive leadership and management experience at the highest levels of a global public company; significant experience with international operations and accounting and financial reporting.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
|
Bassett Furniture Industries, Inc., 2004–present.
|
ERIC G. JOHNSON
PRESIDENT AND CEO OF
BALDWIN RICHARDSON FOODS COMPANY
|
AGE: 64 DIRECTOR SINCE: 1998
Chair, Finance Committee
Member, Compensation and Executive committees
|
||
CAREER
|
Since 1997, Mr. Johnson has served as President and CEO of Baldwin Foods Company, a privately held manufacturer of products for the food service industry.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Extensive executive management skills; expertise in marketing, finance and the development and execution of corporate strategy; experience in mergers and acquisitions. Through his years of service on our Board, Mr. Johnson has also developed a deep base of knowledge regarding our business and our industry.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
|
SUPERVALU, INC., 2013–present.
|
M. LEANNE LACHMAN
PRESIDENT OF LACHMAN
ASSOCIATES LLC AND EXECUTIVE-IN-RESIDENCE,
COLUMBIA GRADUATE SCHOOL OF BUSINESS
|
AGE: 72 DIRECTOR SINCE: 1985
Chair, Audit Committee
Ms. Lachman also serves as a director of Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York, one of our insurance subsidiaries.
|
||
CAREER
|
Ms. Lachman has served since 2003 as president of Lachman Associates LLC, an independent real estate consultancy, and since 2000 as an Executive-in-Residence at Columbia Business School. Before that she was managing director of Lend Lease Real Estate Investments, a global institutional investment manager.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Extensive background in real estate analysis, investment, management, and development, and international operations. Through more than 25 years of service on our Board, she has acquired a deep understanding of our business, our organization and our industry.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
|
Liberty Property Trust, 1994-present, including service on the audit, compensation and governance committees.
|
ISAIAH TIDWELL
RETIRED EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT
AND GEORGIA WEALTH MANAGEMENT
DIRECTOR OF WACHOVIA BANK, N.A.
|
AGE: 70 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2006
Member, Audit and Corporate Governance committees
|
||
CAREER
|
Before retiring in 2005, Mr. Tidwell was an executive vice president and director of Wealth Management operations for Wachovia Bank in Georgia. During his career at Wachovia, he took on various roles with increasing responsibility, eventually becoming Southern Regional Executive before being promoted to executive vice president. Earlier in his career, Tidwell was employed in various accounting and financial positions with Celanese Corporation.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Extensive experience in banking, financial services and wealth management. Through his years of service on the boards of other public companies, Mr. Tidwell has also developed knowledge of risk assessment practices and a significant understanding of finance and accounting principles.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
PRIOR PUBLIC COMPANY BOARD SERVICE IN PAST 5 YEARS
|
Synder’s–Lance, Inc. (formerly Lance, Inc.), 1995–present.
Harris Teeter Supermarkets, Inc. (formerly Ruddick Corporation), 1999–2014.
|
WILLIAM J. AVERY
RETIRED CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD
AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF
CROWN CORK & SEAL COMPANY, INC.
|
AGE: 74 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2002
Member, Audit and Corporate Governance committees
|
||
CAREER
|
In 2001, Mr. Avery retired as Chairman and CEO of Crown Cork & Seal, a manufacturer of packaging products for consumer goods. Over his long career at that company, he was promoted to a series of positions with increasing responsibility, eventually becoming president before serving as CEO and later as chairman.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Extensive experience in driving strategic direction and leading organizational growth; substantial experience in accounting, financial reporting, marketing and mergers and acquisitions.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
|
None in past 5 years.
|
WILLIAM H. CUNNINGHAM
PROFESSOR AT THE UNIVERSITY
OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN AND JAMES
J. BAYLESS CHAIR FOR FREE ENTERPRISE
AT THE UNIVERSITY'S MCCOMBS SCHOOL
OF BUSINESS
|
AGE: 71 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2006
NON-EXECUTIVE CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD SINCE: 2009
Member, Compensation, Corporate Governance, Executive and Finance committees
|
||
CAREER
|
Mr. Cunningham has been a professor with The University of Texas since 2000. Before that he served as chancellor and CEO of The University of Texas System, as president of The University of Texas at Austin and as dean of the McCombs School of Business.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Substantial experience in accounting, marketing, finance and corporate governance, as well as experience leading a large public institution. Mr. Cunningham also has significant experience serving on public company boards, including over 20 years in our industry as a director of Jefferson-Pilot Corporation, a public insurance company that we acquired in 2006.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
PRIOR PUBLIC COMPANY BOARD SERVICE IN PAST 5 YEARS
|
John Hancock Mutual Funds, 1986–present; and Southwest Airlines Co., 2000–present.
LIN Media LLC, (formerly LIN Television Corporation) 2002–2007 and 2009–2014; and Resolute Energy Corporation, 2009–2015.
|
WILLIAM PORTER PAYNE
CHAIRMAN OF CENTENNIAL HOLDING COMPANY, LLC
|
AGE: 67 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2006
Chair, Corporate Governance Committee
Member, Executive Committee
|
||
CAREER
|
Mr. Payne is the Chairman of Centennial Holding Company, LLC, a real estate investment firm. Previously, Mr. Payne served in an executive management role with Gleacher and Company, an investment banking and asset management firm. He was with Gleacher from 2000 through 2013.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Extensive financial expertise; experience in providing strategic advisory services to complex organizations. Earlier in his career, Mr. Payne was an attorney specializing in commercial real estate transactions and mergers and acquisitions. His breadth of knowledge brings an interdisciplinary set of skills to the Board. He also has expertise in corporate governance, having served on a number of public company boards.
|
||
PRIOR PUBLIC COMPANY BOARD SERVICE IN PAST 5 YEARS
|
Cousins Properties, Inc., 1996–2014.
|
PATRICK S. PITTARD
CHAIRMAN OF PATRICKPITTARD ADVISORS LLC
|
AGE: 69 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2006
Chair, Compensation Committee
Mr. Pittard also serves as a director of Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York, one of our insurance subsidiaries.
|
||
CAREER
|
Mr. Pittard is chairman of PatrickPittard Advisors LLC, a human capital firm providing "C-level" services such as executive search and talent assessment. He also serves as a leadership instructor at the Terry School of Business at the University of Georgia and was the chairman and CEO of ACT Bridge from 2011 to 2013. Before that Mr. Pittard was chairman, president and CEO of Heidrick & Struggles International, Inc., a worldwide provider of executive-level search and leadership services and one of the largest publicly traded global recruiting firms, from which he retired in 2002.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Executive leadership and management experience at the highest levels of a global public company; experience driving strategic organizational growth; expertise in executive compensation, insurance and investments.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
|
Artisan Funds, 2001—present.
|
DENNIS R. GLASS
PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
OF LINCOLN NATIONAL CORPORATION
|
AGE: 65 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2006
Member, Executive Committee
|
||
CAREER
|
Mr. Glass has served as our president since 2006 and our CEO since 2007. He is also President of, and serves on the boards of, our principal insurance subsidiaries. Before our merger with Jefferson-Pilot Corporation, Mr. Glass was President, CEO and a Director of that company.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
A seasoned executive who has served in executive-level positions in the insurance and investment industries for over 30 years, Mr. Glass brings to his role as a director a deep knowledge of our industry, our competitors and our products.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
|
None in past 5 years.
|
GARY C. KELLY
CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD,
PRESIDENT AND CHIEF EXECUTIVE
OFFICER OF SOUTHWEST AIRLINES CO.
|
AGE: 60 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2009
Member, Audit and Finance committees
|
||
CAREER
|
Mr. Kelly has been President and CEO of Southwest Airlines since 2004, and Chairman since 2008. Previously Mr. Kelly held a number of senior-level positions within the Southwest organization, including CFO. Before joining Southwest, Mr. Kelly served as a CPA for a public auditing firm.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Executive leadership and management experience at the highest levels of a public company; ability to provide insights into operational, regulatory and governance matters; substantial expertise in finance, accounting and financial reporting.
|
||
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS
|
Southwest Airlines Co., 2004–present.
|
MICHAEL F. MEE
RETIRED EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT AND CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER OF BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB COMPANY
|
AGE: 72 DIRECTOR SINCE: 2001
Member, Compensation and Finance committees
|
||
CAREER
|
From 1994 to 2001, Mr. Mee was the Executive Vice President and CFO of Bristol-Myers Squibb Co., a pharmaceutical and health care products company, where he was also a member of the Office of the Chairman. Before joining Bristol-Myers Squibb, Mr. Mee served in senior financial executive positions with several Fortune 500 companies.
|
||
QUALIFICATIONS
|
Significant public accounting and financial reporting skills; extensive management experience and leadership skills; expertise in corporate strategy, development and investments, international operations and risk assessment.
|
||
PRIOR PUBLIC COMPANY BOARD SERVICE IN PAST 5 YEARS
|
Ferro Corporation, 2001–2010.
|
·
|
We provide competitive compensation to attract and retain high-quality outside directors; and
|
·
|
A significant portion of each outside director’s compensation is paid in equity to help align our directors’ interests with those of our shareholders.
|
FEES
|
2014
|
2015
|
||
Board
|
||||
Annual Retainer (Cash)
|
$ 86,000
|
$ 86,000
|
||
Deferred LNC Stock Units
|
$146,000
|
$161,000
|
||
Total Board Fees
|
$232,000
|
$247,000
|
||
Non-Executive Chairman of the Board
|
||||
Deferred LNC Stock Units
|
$200,000
|
$200,000
|
||
Committees (Cash)
|
||||
Audit Committee Chair
|
$30,000
|
$30,000
|
||
Audit Committee Member
|
$10,000
|
$10,000
|
||
Other Committee Chair
|
$10,000
|
$10,000
|
||
·
|
Financial planning services—up to $20,000 for an initial financial plan and $10,000 for annual updates. The services must be provided by a Lincoln Financial Network financial planner for the director to be reimbursed.
|
·
|
Participation—at their own expense—in certain health and welfare benefits, including our self-insured medical and dental plans as well as life insurance and accidental death and dismemberment coverages.
|
·
|
Participation in a matching charitable gift program through which the Lincoln Financial Foundation, Inc. matches donations from a director to one or more eligible organizations, up to an annual total of $15,000 for all gifts.
|
COMPENSATION OF DIRECTORS* DURING 2014
|
||||||||||||||||
NAME
|
FEES EARNED
OR PAID IN
CASH1
($)
|
STOCK
AWARDS2
($)
|
ALL OTHER
COMPENSATION
($)
|
TOTAL
($)
|
||||||||||||
William J. Avery
|
96,000 | 146,000 | 25,000 | 3,4 | 267,000 | |||||||||||
William H. Cunningham
|
86,000 | 346,000 | 15,000 | 4 | 447,000 | |||||||||||
George W. Henderson, III
|
115,400 | 146,000 | - | 261,400 | ||||||||||||
Eric G. Johnson
|
96,000 | 146,000 | 20,000 | 3 | 262,000 | |||||||||||
Gary C. Kelly
|
96,000 | 146,000 | 15,000 | 4 | 257,000 | |||||||||||
M. Leanne Lachman
|
135,400 | 146,000 | 15,000 | 4 | 296,400 | |||||||||||
Michael F. Mee
|
86,000 | 146,000 | - | 232,000 | ||||||||||||
William Porter Payne
|
96,000 | 146,000 | 15,000 | 4 | 257,000 | |||||||||||
Patrick S. Pittard
|
115,400 | 146,000 | 35,000 | 3,4 | 296,400 | |||||||||||
Isaiah Tidwell
|
96,000 | 146,000 | 15,000 | 4 | 257,500 |
Name
|
Deferred LNC
Stock Units
|
Stock
Options
|
William J. Avery
|
33,101
|
25,105
|
William H. Cunningham
|
75,622
|
41,359
|
George W. Henderson, III
|
50,137
|
41,359
|
Eric G. Johnson
|
42,986
|
33,180
|
Gary C. Kelly
|
14,442
|
17,040
|
M. Leanne Lachman
|
53,047
|
33,180
|
Michael F. Mee
|
56,243
|
33,180
|
William Porter Payne
|
31,200
|
33,284
|
Patrick S. Pittard
|
33,317
|
41,359
|
Isaiah Tidwell
|
25,793
|
39,314
|
Fiscal Year
Ended –
December 31, 2014
|
% of
Total Fees
|
Fiscal Year
Ended –
December 31, 2013
|
% of
Total Fees
|
||||
Audit Fees1
|
$9,841,680
|
88.0
|
$9,848,970
|
91.5
|
|||
Audit-Related Fees2
|
1,222,782
|
10.9
|
908,198
|
8.4
|
|||
Tax Fees3
|
115,164
|
1.0
|
8,788
|
0.1
|
|||
All Other Fees
|
0.0
|
||||||
TOTAL FEES:
|
$11,179,626
|
100
|
$10,765,956
|
100
|
1.
|
Audit Fees. Fees for audit services include fees and expenses associated with the annual audit, the reviews of our interim financial statements included in quarterly reports on Form 10-Q, accounting consultations directly associated with the audit, and services normally provided in connection with statutory and regulatory filings.
|
2.
|
Audit-Related Fees. Audit-related services principally include employee benefit plan audits, service auditor reports on internal controls, due diligence procedures in connection with acquisitions and dispositions, reviews of registration statements and prospectuses, and accounting consultations not directly associated with the audit or quarterly reviews.
|
3.
|
Tax Fees. Fees for tax services include tax-filing and advisory services.
|
·
|
preparing our financial statements;
|
·
|
establishing financial reporting systems and internal controls; and
|
·
|
reporting on the effectiveness of our internal control over financial reporting.
|
·
|
performing an independent audit of our consolidated financial statements;
|
·
|
issuing a report on those financial statements; and
|
·
|
issuing an attestation report on our internal control over financial reporting.
|
·
|
reviewed and discussed with management the audited financial statements for fiscal year 2014;
|
·
|
discussed with our accounting firm the matters that the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (“PCAOB”) requires them to discuss as per Auditing Standard No. 16, Communications with Audit Committee;
|
·
|
received the written disclosures and letter from our accounting firm that the PCAOB requires regarding the firm’s communications with the Audit Committee concerning independence; and
|
·
|
discussed with our accounting firm that firm’s independence.
|
·
|
align the interests of our executive officers with those of our shareholders;
|
·
|
attract, motivate and retain key executives who are crucial to our long-term success; and
|
·
|
link executive pay directly to the attainment of short- and long-term financial/business goals, which we refer to as "pay for performance."
|
This Compensation Discussion and Analysis (“CD&A”) contains information about:
|
|
•
|
our foundational pay-for-performance compensation philosophy
|
•
|
the structure of our compensation programs and the reasoning behind this structure
|
•
|
how compensation decisions are made and how our compensation programs are administered
|
•
|
the compensation we paid under our performance-based incentive programs for performance periods ending in 2014, and how it related to our short and long-term performance results
|
·
|
Robust stock ownership guidelines and stock holding requirements;
|
·
|
Moderate change-of-control benefits;
|
·
|
The use of an independent compensation consultant for significant compensation decisions regarding our executives;
|
·
|
“Double trigger” vesting provisions for our equity awards following our change of control;
|
·
|
Clawback provisions on our equity awards;
|
·
|
No tax-gross-up benefits upon our change of control;
|
·
|
No repricing or exchange of underwater stock options without shareholder approval;
|
·
|
Restrictions regarding pledging, hedging and speculation in our securities; and
|
·
|
Limited perquisites for executive officers.
|
COMPENSATION
ELEMENT
|
WHAT IT REWARDS
|
HOW IT ALIGNS
WITH OUR OBJECTIVES
|
PERFORMANCE MEASURED
|
FIXED OR VARIABLE
|
CASH OR EQUITY
|
BASE SALARY
|
· Sustained high level of performance
· Demonstrated success in meeting or exceeding key objectives
· Highly developed skills and abilities critical to success of the business
· Experience and time in position
|
· Competitive base salaries enable us to attract and retain top talent
· Merit-based salary increases align with our pay-for-performance philosophy
|
INDIVIDUAL
|
FIXED
|
CASH
|
ANNUAL
INCENTIVE
AWARDS
|
· Company performance during the year against key financial goals
· Specific business-segment performance during the year, measured against strategic business-segment goals
|
· Competitive targets enable us to attract and retain top talent
· Payouts depend on the achievement of established performance measures and goals that align pay with performance
|
CORPORATE
AND BUSINESS SEGMENT
|
VARIABLE
|
CASH
|
LONG-TERM INCENTIVE AWARDS
|
|||||
NON-QUALIFIED
STOCK OPTIONS
|
· Increase in stock price
· Continued service
|
· Value is dependent on our stock price; options have no value unless the stock price increases
· Three-year ratable vesting supports retention
|
CORPORATE
|
VARIABLE
|
EQUITY
|
RESTRICTED
STOCK UNITS
|
· Increase in stock price and dividends
· Continued service
|
· Value rises or falls as our stock price increases or decreases
· Three-year cliff vesting supports retention
|
CORPORATE
|
VARIABLE
|
EQUITY
|
PERFORMANCE SHARES
|
· Meeting or exceeding our return on equity goal
· Total shareholder return performance relative to that of other companies
|
· Payout is based on metrics important to our shareholders and critical to value creation
· Three-year performance period supports retention and aligns pay with performance over an extended period of time
· Relative performance metric creates incentive to outperform peers
|
CORPORATE
|
VARIABLE
|
EQUITY
|
PAY-FOR-PERFORMANCE
To link executive pay directly to the attainment of short-term and long-term financial/business goals, using short-term metrics that correlate with our strategic goals and long-term metrics that correlate to long-term shareholder value
|
ALIGNMENT WITH SHAREHOLDERS
To provide incentives that link the interests of our executive officers to those of our shareholders
|
COMPETITIVE COMPENSATION
To attract and retain key executive talent
|
·
|
reward the achievement of superior financial results — in both the short term and long term — through balanced incentive programs;
|
·
|
offer the opportunity to earn above-market compensation when overall and individual performance exceed expectations; and
|
·
|
emphasize compensation that is at risk based on performance rather than compensation that is fixed—for instance, only 11% of the CEO’s target annual pay is fixed.
|
|
·
|
Our AIP is based on measures that are key financial measures indicative of Lincoln’s current and future profitability; and
|
|
·
|
Our LTI uses measures that correlate directly to the creation of long-term value for Lincoln shareholders.
|
2014 ANNUAL INCENTIVE PROGRAM
|
|
PERFORMANCE MEASURE
|
WHY CHOSEN
|
INCOME FROM OPERATIONS PER DILUTED SHARE
|
This is a key measure of profitability that management uses to evaluate our business and that investors commonly use to value companies in the financial services industry.
|
SALES GROWTH
|
In our business, sales create value because, over time and at a compounded growth rate, they are an indicator of future profitability. In addition, we believe that distribution strength (depth and breadth) is an important driver of valuation and that sales growth is an effective way to measure the value of the distribution franchise and overall product competitiveness.
|
CONTROLLABLE COSTS
|
Management establishes annual budgets for the Company and for each business unit that are key to the success of our financial plan. The Compensation Committee sets a budget-related performance goal to reinforce the importance of containing costs and expenses across the entire company.
|
2014 LONG-TERM INCENTIVE PROGRAM
|
|
PERFORMANCE MEASURE
|
WHY CHOSEN
|
OPERATING RETURN ON EQUITY
|
This is an important measure that stock analysts use to value companies — especially those in the financial services industry — because it is a critical indicator of capital efficiency and is closely aligned with long-term shareholder value.
|
RELATIVE TOTAL SHAREHOLDER RETURN
|
This measure reflects the Company’s delivery of shareholder value over time relative to that of our peers.
|
·
|
Performance share awards (“PSAs”) – the number of shares actually received on payout of these awards depends on our performance over a three-year period relative to key metrics of shareholder value;
|
·
|
Restricted stock units (“RSUs”) – these awards cliff-vest three years from the date of grant (cliff-vesting acts as a retention tool for our executives) and the value ultimately realized depends on how our stock performs over that three-year period; and
|
·
|
Non-qualified stock options to purchase our common stock (“Options”) – these awards vest over time and only have value if the stock price rises after the option grants are made.
|
·
|
shares owned outright;
|
·
|
amounts invested in shares of our common stock through our employee benefits plans;
|
·
|
restricted stock and RSUs; and
|
·
|
in-the-money vested Options.
|
SHARE OWNERSHIP AND HOLDING REQUIREMENTS
|
||
OFFICER POSITION
|
VALUE OF SHARES THAT
OFFICER MUST HOLD
|
ADDITIONAL HOLDING REQUIREMENTS
|
CEO
|
7 times base salary
|
25% of net profit shares* for 5 years
|
Executive Officers
(other than the CEO)
|
4 times base salary
|
25% of net profit shares* for 5 years
|
·
|
the executive’s employment is terminated for cause; or
|
·
|
the executive violates any non-compete, non-disclosure, non-solicitation, non-disparagement or other restrictive agreement.
|
AFLAC
|
JOHN HANCOCK
|
|
AIG
|
METLIFE
|
|
ALLSTATE
|
PHOENIX COMPANIES
|
|
AXA GROUP
|
PRINCIPAL FINANCIAL
|
|
CIGNA
|
PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL
|
|
CNO FINANCIAL
|
SUN LIFE FINANCIAL
|
|
GENWORTH FINANCIAL
|
TRANSAMERICA
|
|
HARTFORD FINANCIAL SERVICES
|
UNUM GROUP
|
|
ING
|
·
|
organizational considerations; for example, because an executive's role is considered especially critical to our overall business strategy and to our succession planning;
|
·
|
internal pay equity considerations;
|
·
|
to gain the specific expertise needed to build a new business or improve an existing one; or
|
·
|
to retain highly qualified executives whom we have recruited from outside the insurance industry or whom we believe have skills or experience that will further our corporate strategy.
|
·
|
Mr. Cornelio has served as president of Retirement Plan Services since December 2009 and also serves as chief administrative officer, overseeing the Company’s Information Technology and Shared Services areas. In view of this dual role, the Compensation Committee reviewed compensation data for executives in similar positions from the McLagan Partners’ Investment Management Survey for 2013, as well as for companies from the Towers Watson 2013 Financial Services Executive Compensation Survey and the 2013 Towers DI Study. For a list of the companies included in the McLagan Partners’ Survey and the Towers Watson Survey, see Exhibit 2 beginning on page E-4. Mr. Cornelio announced his retirement from the Company, which is effective April 15, 2015.
|
·
|
As president of Lincoln Financial Group Distribution, Mr. Fuller is responsible for our wholesale and retail distribution businesses. Therefore, the Compensation Committee reviewed compensation data for executives in similar positions from the McLagan Partners’ Investment Products Sales and Marketing Survey for 2013, as well as from the companies in the 2013 Towers DI Study. For a list of the companies included in the McLagan Partners’ Investment Products Sales and Marketing Survey, see Exhibit 3 on page E-6.
|
·
|
the recommendations of our Chief Human Resources Officer, the recommendations of our CEO (only with respect to NEOs other than himself), and the opinion of its compensation consultant;
|
·
|
the available market data; and
|
·
|
reports called “tally sheets” illustrating all elements of targeted total direct compensation, including:
|
|
·
|
base salary;
|
|
·
|
annual and long-term incentive awards;
|
|
·
|
deferred compensation and change in pension;
|
|
·
|
perquisites; and
|
|
·
|
potential payments for various termination scenarios.
|
2014 TARGET TOTAL DIRECT COMPENSATION FOR OUR NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
|
||||
NAME
|
BASE SALARY
|
ANNUAL
INCENTIVE
AWARD
AT TARGET
|
LONG-TERM INCENTIVE
AWARD AT
TARGET
|
TOTAL
TARGETED
ANNUAL COMPENSATION
|
Dennis R. Glass
|
$1,135,000
|
$2,270,000
|
$6,750,000
|
$10,155,000
|
Randal J. Freitag
|
$575,384
|
$690,461
|
$1,404,156
|
$2,670,001
|
Charles C. Cornelio
|
$581,507
|
$785,035
|
$1,158,458
|
$2,525,000
|
Wilford H. Fuller
|
$484,000
|
$1,161,600
|
$1,179,145
|
$2,824,745
|
Mark E. Konen
|
$644,008
|
$901,611
|
$1,523,150
|
$3,068,769
|
Dennis R. Glass
|
$1,135,000
|
Randal J. Freitag
|
$575,384
|
Charles C. Cornelio
|
$581,507
|
Wilford H. Fuller
|
$484,000
|
Mark E. Konen
|
$644,008
|
ESTIMATED PAYOUT OPPORTUNITIES UNDER THE 2014 AIP
|
|||
NAME
|
THRESHOLD
|
TARGET
|
MAXIMUM
|
Dennis R. Glass
|
$34,050
|
$2,270,000
|
$4,540,000
|
Randal J. Freitag
|
$10,357
|
$690,461
|
$1,380,921
|
Charles C. Cornelio
|
$14,719
|
$785,035
|
$1,570,069
|
Wilford H. Fuller
|
$14,520
|
$1,161,600
|
$2,323,200
|
Mark E. Konen
|
$25,470
|
$901,611
|
$1,803,221
|
·
|
Income from Operations per Share
|
·
|
Sales growth
|
·
|
Management of controllable costs
|
|
·
|
Aligning incentives with our annual financial plan;
|
|
·
|
Establishing challenging yet achievable incentive targets for our executives; and
|
|
·
|
Setting targets that are consistent with our assessment of opportunities and risks for the upcoming year.
|
CORPORATE MEASURES 100%
SALES GROWTH
|
||||||
INCOME FROM OPERATIONS
PER SHARE
|
ENTERPRISE CONTROLLABLE
COSTS
|
|||||
LIFE
|
GROUP PROTECTION
|
ANNUITIES
|
RETIREMENT
PLAN SERVICES
|
|||
GOALS
|
||||||
Threshold
|
$4.85
|
$658 M
|
$449 M
|
$12,203 M
|
$6,560 M
|
N/A
|
Target
|
$5.33
|
$748 M
|
$510 M
|
$13,867 M
|
$7,455 M
|
100%
|
Maximum
|
$5.97
|
$837 M
|
$571 M
|
$15,531 M
|
$8,349 M
|
89%
|
RESULTS
|
||||||
Certified
Performance
|
$5.81
|
$669 M
|
$484 M
|
$13,778 M
|
$7,515 M
|
96.6%
|
Payout as a
percentage of Target
|
175.0%
|
34.2%
|
68.0%
|
96.0%
|
106.7%
|
130.1%
|
Weighting
|
50.0%
|
11.0%
|
8.0%
|
10.0%
|
6.0%
|
15.0%
|
Weighted Payout
|
87.5%
|
3.8%
|
5.4%
|
9.6%
|
6.4%
|
19.5%
|
TARGET
OPPORTUNITY
|
PAYOUT PERCENTAGE
(sum of weighted payouts)
|
PAYOUT
AMOUNT
|
|
ACTUAL PAYOUTS UNDER 2014 AIP
|
$2,270,000
|
132.2%
|
$3,000,940
|
CORPORATE MEASURES 92.5%
SALES GROWTH
|
BUSINESS UNIT MEASURES
|
||||||
INCOME FROM OPERATIONS
PER SHARE
|
ENTERPRISE CONTROLLABLE COSTS
|
CONTROLLABLE COSTS
FINANCE
|
|||||
LIFE
|
GROUP PROTECTION
|
ANNUITIES
|
RETIREMENT PLAN SERVICES
|
||||
GOALS
|
|||||||
Threshold
|
$4.85
|
$658 M
|
$449 M
|
$12,203 M
|
$6,560 M
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
Target
|
$5.33
|
$748 M
|
$510 M
|
$13,867 M
|
$7,455 M
|
100%
|
100%
|
Maximum
|
$5.97
|
$837 M
|
$571 M
|
$15,531 M
|
$8,349 M
|
89%
|
90%
|
RESULTS
|
|||||||
Certified Performance
|
$5.81
|
$669 M
|
$484 M
|
$13,778 M
|
$7,515 M
|
96.6%
|
99.6%
|
Payout as a percentage of Target
|
175.0%
|
34.2%
|
68.0%
|
96.0%
|
106.7%
|
130.1%
|
104.2%
|
Weighting
|
50.0%
|
11.0%
|
8.0%
|
10.0%
|
6.0%
|
7.5%
|
7.5%
|
Weighted Payout
|
87.5%
|
3.8%
|
5.4%
|
9.6%
|
6.4%
|
9.8%
|
7.8%
|
TARGET
OPPORTUNITY
|
PAYOUT PERCENTAGE
(sum of weighted payouts)
|
PAYOUT
AMOUNT
|
|
ACTUAL PAYOUTS UNDER 2014 AIP
|
$690,461
|
130.3%
|
$889,670
|
CORPORATE MEASURES
|
BUSINESS UNIT MEASURES (75%)
|
||||||
INCOME FROM OPERATIONS PER SHARE
|
INCOME FROM OPERATIONS
RPS
|
SALES GROWTH
RPS
|
CONTROLLABLE COSTS
RPS
|
SALES GROWTH
LIFE
|
SALES GROWTH
ANNUITIES
|
CONTROLLABLE COSTS
SS/IT
|
|
GOALS
|
|||||||
Threshold
|
$4.85
|
$121 M
|
$6,560 M
|
N/A
|
$658 M
|
$12,203 M
|
N/A
|
Target
|
$5.33
|
$138 M
|
$7,455 M
|
100%
|
$748 M
|
$13,867 M
|
100%
|
Maximum
|
$5.97
|
$160 M
|
$8,349 M
|
90%
|
$837 M
|
$15,531 M
|
90%
|
RESULTS
|
|||||||
Certified Performance
|
$5.81
|
$160 M
|
$7,515 M
|
100.0%
|
$669 M
|
$13,778 M
|
95.6%
|
Payout as a percentage of Target
|
175.0%
|
200.0%
|
106.7%
|
100.0%
|
34.2%
|
96.0%
|
143.5%
|
Weighting
|
25.0%
|
25.0%
|
20.0%
|
5.0%
|
7.5%
|
7.5%
|
10.0%
|
Weighted Payout
|
43.8%
|
50.0%
|
21.3%
|
5.0%
|
2.6%
|
7.2%
|
14.4%
|
TARGET
OPPORTUNITY
|
PAYOUT PERCENTAGE
(sum of weighted payouts)
|
PAYOUT
AMOUNT
|
|
ACTUAL PAYOUTS UNDER 2014 AIP
|
$785,035
|
144.2%
|
$1,132,020
|
CORPORATE MEASURES
|
BUSINESS UNIT MEASURES (70%)
|
||||||
INCOME FROM OPERATIONS PER SHARE
|
LFD NET CONTRIBUTION MARGIN
|
LFN NET CONTRIBUTION MARGIN
|
SALES GROWTH
|
CONTROLLABLE COSTS
LFD & LFN
|
|||
LIFE
|
ANNUITIES
|
RPS
SMALL MARKET
|
|||||
GOALS
|
|||||||
Threshold
|
$4.85
|
$2.7 M
|
($2.7) M
|
$658 M
|
$12,203 M
|
$1,659 M
|
N/A
|
Target
|
$5.33
|
$12.7 M
|
$7.3 M
|
$748 M
|
$13,867 M
|
$1,885 M
|
100%
|
Maximum
|
$5.97
|
$22.7 M
|
$17.3 M
|
$837 M
|
$15,531 M
|
$2,111 M
|
85%
|
RESULTS
|
|||||||
Certified Performance
|
$5.81
|
$17.8
|
$12.4 M
|
$669 M
|
$13,778 M
|
$1,812 M
|
92.8%
|
Payout as a percentage of Target
|
175.0%
|
151.0%
|
151.0%
|
34.2%
|
96.0%
|
75.8%
|
147.8%
|
Weighting
|
30.0%
|
10.0%
|
10.0%
|
15.0%
|
15.0%
|
5.0%
|
15.0%
|
Weighted Payout
|
52.5%
|
15.1%
|
15.1%
|
5.1%
|
14.4%
|
3.8%
|
22.2%
|
TARGET
OPPORTUNITY
|
PAYOUT PERCENTAGE
(sum of weighted payouts)
|
PAYOUT
AMOUNT
|
|
ACTUAL PAYOUTS UNDER 2014 AIP
|
$1,161,600
|
128.2%
|
$1,489,171
|
CORPORATE MEASURES
|
BUSINESS UNIT MEASURES (80%)
|
|||||||
INCOME FROM OPERATIONS PER SHARE
|
INCOME FROM OPERATIONS
|
SALES GROWTH
|
CONTROLLABLE COSTS IS AND ANNUITIES
|
|||||
LIFE
|
GROUP PROTECTION
|
ANNUITIES
|
LIFE
|
GROUP PROTECTION
|
ANNUITIES
|
|||
GOALS
|
||||||||
Threshold
|
$4.85
|
$464 M
|
$62 M
|
$739 M
|
$658 M
|
$449 M
|
$12,203 M
|
N/A
|
Target
|
$5.33
|
$527 M
|
$71 M
|
$840 M
|
$748 M
|
$510 M
|
$13,867 M
|
100%
|
Maximum
|
$5.97
|
$612 M
|
$82 M
|
$974 M
|
$837 M
|
$571 M
|
$15,531 M
|
90%
|
RESULTS
|
||||||||
Certified Performance
|
$6.03
|
$612 M
|
$23 M
|
$925 M
|
$669 M
|
$484 M
|
$13,778 M
|
98.3%
|
Payout as a
percentage of
Target
|
200.0%
|
200.0%
|
0.0%
|
164.3%
|
34.2%
|
68.0%
|
96.0%
|
116.5%
|
Weighting
|
20.0%
|
12.0%
|
12.0%
|
12.0%
|
11.3%
|
11.4%
|
11.3%
|
10.0%
|
Weighted Payout
|
40.0%
|
24.0%
|
0.0%
|
19.6%
|
3.9%
|
7.8%
|
10.8%
|
11.7%
|
TARGET
OPPORTUNITY
|
PAYOUT PERCENTAGE
(sum of weighted payouts)
|
PAYOUT
AMOUNT
|
|
ACTUAL PAYOUTS UNDER 2014 AIP
|
$901,611
|
117.7%
|
$1,061,196
|
·
|
Options, which have a 10-year term and vest ratably over three years;
|
·
|
RSUs, which cliff-vest in three years; and
|
·
|
PSAs, which vest, if at all, depending on the outcome of pre-established performance measures over a three-year performance period. Consistent with our fundamental pay-for-performance philosophy, these awards are linked to metrics that measure the creation of long-term shareholder value, with above-target compensation paid out only when performance has exceeded the target level. PSA payouts are capped at two times target.
|
·
|
the threshold, target, and maximum PSA amounts payable to the NEOs;
|
·
|
the relevant performance measures (ROE and Relative TSR);
|
·
|
the relative weighting of each performance measure; and
|
·
|
the goals for threshold, target and maximum payouts for each performance measure.
|
Return on Equity (ROE)
Why Chosen: A key measure of our financial health that management uses to evaluate our business and that is also used by investors to value companies in the financial services industry. It provides a meaningful measure of performance that is closely tied to long-term shareholder value.
Relative Weight: 50%
|
Relative Total Shareholder Return (TSR)
Why Chosen: Assesses the Company’s delivery of shareholder value over time relative to that of our peers.
Relative weight: 50%
|
||||
GOAL AT
THRESHOLD
11%
|
GOAL AT
TARGET
11.65%
|
GOAL AT
MAXIMUM
12.30%
|
GOAL AT
THRESHOLD
RANKING OF
8th
|
GOAL AT
TARGET
MEDIAN OF
PEER GROUP
|
GOAL AT
MAXIMUM
RANKING OF
1ST TO 3RD
|
GENWORTH FINANCIAL
|
PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL
|
MANULIFE
|
SUN LIFE FINANCIAL
|
METLIFE
|
SYMMETRA FINANCIAL
|
PRINCIPAL FINANCIAL
|
TORCHMARK
|
PROTECTIVE LIFE
|
UNUM GROUP
|
ESTIMATED SHARE PAYOUT OPPORTUNITIES UNDER
THE 2014-2016 PERFORMANCE AWARD CYCLE AS OF GRANT DATE*
|
|||
NAME
|
THRESHOLD (#)
|
TARGET (#)
|
MAXIMUM (#)
|
Dennis R. Glass
|
5,817
|
46,534
|
93,068
|
Randal J. Freitag
|
1,383
|
11,063
|
22,126
|
Charles C. Cornelio
|
1,141
|
9,128
|
18,256
|
Wilford H. Fuller
|
1,161
|
9,291
|
18,582
|
Mark E. Konen
|
1,500
|
12,001
|
24,002
|
·
|
the threshold, target and maximum PSA amounts payable to the NEOs;
|
·
|
the relevant performance measures (ROE and Relative TSR);
|
·
|
the relative weighting of each performance measure; and
|
·
|
the goals for threshold, target and maximum payouts for each performance measure (25%, 100% and 200% of target, respectively).
|
ESTIMATED SHARE PAYOUT OPPORTUNITIES UNDER
THE 2012-2014 PERFORMANCE AWARD CYCLE AS OF GRANT DATE*
|
|||
NAME
|
THRESHOLD (#)
|
TARGET (#)
|
MAXIMUM (#)
|
Dennis R. Glass
|
10,356
|
82,845
|
165,690
|
Randal J. Freitag
|
2,196
|
17,570
|
35,140
|
Charles C. Cornelio
|
1,608
|
12,862
|
25,724
|
Wilford H. Fuller
|
1,734
|
13,871
|
27,742
|
Mark E. Konen
|
2,603
|
20,820
|
41,640
|
Return on Equity (ROE)
Relative weight: 50%
|
Relative Total Shareholder Return (TSR)
Relative weight: 50%
|
|||||
GOAL AT
THRESHOLD
10%
|
GOAL AT
TARGET
10.5%
|
GOAL AT
MAXIMUM
11%
|
GOAL AT THRESHOLD
RANKING OF
8th
|
GOAL AT
TARGET
MEDIAN OF
PEER GROUP
|
GOAL AT MAXIMUM
RANKING OF
1ST TO 3RD
|
|
ACTUAL
RESULTS
12.7%
|
PAYOUT AS PERCENTAGE
OF TARGET
200%
|
ACTUAL
RESULTS
2nd IN PEER GROUP
(TSR OF 204.8%)
|
PAYOUT AS
PERCENTAGE OF TARGET
200%
|
GENWORTH FINANCIAL
|
PROTECTIVE LIFE
|
|
HARTFORD FINANCIAL SERVICES
|
PRUDENTIAL FINANCIAL
|
|
MANULIFE
|
SUN LIFE FINANCIAL
|
|
METLIFE
|
TORCHMARK
|
|
PRINCIPAL FINANCIAL
|
UNUM GROUP
|
ACTUAL PAYOUTS UNDER 2012-2014 PERFORMANCE SHARE AWARDS
|
|||
NAME
|
TARGET
(# OF SHARES)
|
PAYOUT
PERCENTAGE
OF TARGET
|
PAYOUT
(# OF SHARES)1
|
Dennis R. Glass
|
82,845
|
200%
|
165,690
|
Randal J. Freitag
|
17,570
|
200%
|
35,140
|
Charles C. Cornelio
|
12,862
|
200%
|
25,724
|
Wilford H. Fuller
|
13,871
|
200%
|
27,742
|
Mark E. Konen
|
20,820
|
200%
|
41,640
|
·
|
approves the individual pay components and aggregate compensation amounts for our executives;
|
·
|
determines the form(s) in which compensation will be paid — i.e., cash or equity — and the equity vehicles to be used, including Options, PSAs or RSUs, among others; and
|
·
|
establishes the target award levels and performance measures for the various short- and long-term compensation programs.
|
·
|
their assessment of individual performance, the business environment, succession planning and retention; and
|
·
|
recommendations for base salary, target annual incentive awards and target long-term incentive awards for each NEO except our CEO.
|
·
|
an evaluation of executive officers’ base salaries and short- and long-term target incentive compensation relative to that of identified peers and the broader market;
|
·
|
an evaluation of the alignment of the Company’s executive compensation with Company performance;
|
·
|
information on trends in executive compensation, such as the use of various forms of equity compensation and the prevalence of different types of compensation vehicles;
|
·
|
an evaluation of the impact of the Company’s equity programs on the pool of shares available for grant;
|
·
|
an advance review of all management-prepared materials for each Committee meeting;
|
·
|
assistance in the review and discussion of all material agenda items;
|
·
|
an independent review of our analytical work related to executive compensation;
|
·
|
insight and advice in connection with the design of, and changes to, our equity grants and short- and long-term incentive plans; and
|
·
|
feedback regarding our CEO's total targeted direct compensation package.
|
·
|
identifying all of the compensation programs that cover our employees;
|
·
|
reviewing these programs from a design and governance perspective, including evaluating the behavior each program was designed to encourage and detailing the flow of compensation for each program;
|
·
|
identifying any risks inherent in the programs, including analyzing whether any of the programs encourage our executives or any other employees to take risks that could harm the Company; and
|
·
|
identifying and discussing any additional risk mitigation factors in the program design and any additional risk controls outside of the compensation process specific to each business model.
|
·
|
our incentive plan awards are based on a variety of performance indicators, thus minimizing the potential for any single indicator of performance to have an undue influence on payout;
|
·
|
the Compensation Committee approves the final incentive plan awards and has the authority to decrease the awards even if the performance goals are met;
|
·
|
the “clawback” features of our equity awards, which allow us to rescind an executive's award(s) under certain conditions;
|
·
|
the multi-year performance criteria for our LTI programs and the multi-year vesting elements of our other equity awards, which link the interests of our executives with the long-term health of the Company;
|
·
|
the balanced pay mix, which minimizes the significance of any single element of pay and decreases the likelihood that an executive would take inappropriate risks to inflate such pay;
|
·
|
our share ownership guidelines and holding requirements, which encourage our executives to focus on sustaining long-term performance rather than maximizing performance in any single year; and
|
·
|
fixed compensation is set at a level that allows executives to meet their essential financial needs.
|
·
|
For equity awards granted to executives at a regularly scheduled meeting of the Board or Committee, the grant date is the date of the meeting.
|
·
|
For equity awards granted at a “special” meeting of the Board or Committee that does not occur during the period in which trading of our securities is permitted under our Insider Trading and Confidentiality Policy (a “window period”), the grant becomes effective on the first business day of the next window period. (Window periods generally begin on the later of the second business day after our quarterly earnings release or the first business day after our public call with investors.)
|
·
|
For equity awards granted by written consent, the grant becomes effective on the first business day of the week following the effective date of the written consent; however, if that business day is not during a window period, the grant becomes effective on the first business day of the next window period.
|
·
|
For PSAs, the Committee may reduce the target award or payout for any “covered employee” or increase or decrease any other executive’s individual payout, based on certain circumstances that may occur during the cycle.
|
·
|
The Committee may also pay non-performance-based compensation to "covered employees" based on circumstances that could affect performance results, such as changing economic and market conditions, mergers or acquisitions, sale of a business, restructuring charges, reserve strengthening or release, and/or extraordinary natural occurrences or man-made events (e.g., acts of war). In doing so, the Committee would consider various factors, including investor reaction, stock price performance, performance of peers, retention considerations, and the CEO’s recommendation.
|
·
|
retain qualified executives in the face of an actual or threatened change of control of the Company;
|
·
|
enable executives to help our Board assess any proposed change of control of the Company and advise whether such a proposal is in the best interests of the Company, our shareholders, our policyholders and customers without being unduly influenced by the possibility of employment termination; and
|
·
|
demonstrate to those executives our desire to treat them fairly and competitively in such circumstances.
|
NAME AND
PRINCIPAL POSITION
|
YEAR
|
SALARY
($)
|
BONUS
($)
|
STOCK
AWARDS
($)1
|
OPTION AWARDS
($)2
|
NON-EQUITY INCENTIVE
PLAN
COMPENSATION
($)3
|
CHANGE IN PENSION VALUE AND NON-QUALIFIED DEFERRED COMPENSATION EARNINGS
($)4
|
ALL OTHER COMPENSATION
($)5
|
TOTAL
($)6
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
2014
|
1,135,000 |
__
|
5,589,052 | 1,350,010 | 3,000,940 | 272,177 | 848,154 | 12,195,333 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
DENNIS R. GLASS
|
2013
|
1,100,000 |
__
|
4,204,470 | 2,135,005 | 3,999,600 |
__
|
739,083 | 12,178,158 | |||||||||||||||||||||
President and CEO of LNC
|
2012
|
1,075,000 |
__
|
4,247,938 | 2,069,453 | 3,104,600 | 173,443 | 671,779 | 11,342,213 | |||||||||||||||||||||
2014
|
575,384 |
__
|
1,027,891 | 421,258 | 899,670 | 55,425 | 258,141 | 3,237,769 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
RANDAL J. FREITAG
|
2013
|
558,625 |
__
|
885,969 | 449,876 | 1,100,235 |
__
|
220,232 | 3,214,937 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Executive Vice President
and CFO
|
2012
|
545,000 |
__
|
900,900 | 438,881 | 871,074 | 27,929 | 186,252 | 2,970,036 | |||||||||||||||||||||
CHARLES C. CORNELIO7
|
2014
|
581,507 |
__
|
848,074 | 347,540 | 1,132,020 | 92,363 | 272,335 | 3,273,839 | |||||||||||||||||||||
President, Retirement Plan
Services (Retired)
|
2013
|
564,570 |
__
|
700,467 | 355,683 | 1,150,876 |
__
|
220,656 | 2,992,252 | |||||||||||||||||||||
2014
|
484,000 |
__
|
863,206 | 353,752 | 1,489,171 |
__
|
365,026 | 3,555,155 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
WILFORD H. FULLER
|
2013
|
484,000 |
__
|
784,009 | 398,093 | 2,103,658 |
__
|
307,934 | 4,077,694 | |||||||||||||||||||||
President, Lincoln Financial
Group Distribution
|
2012
|
440,000 |
__
|
911,260 | 346,485 | 1,641,200 |
__
|
245,685 | 3,584,630 | |||||||||||||||||||||
2014
|
644,008 |
__
|
1,115,015 | 456,950 | 1,061,196 | 114,854 | 308,849 | 3,700,872 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
MARK E. KONEN
|
2013
|
625,250 |
__
|
1,049,887 | 533,107 | 1,323,529 |
__
|
276,995 | 3,808,768 | |||||||||||||||||||||
President, Insurance and
Retirement Solutions
|
2012
|
610,000 |
__
|
1,067,571 | 520,077 | 1,146,922 | 60,057 | 265,813 | 3,670,440 |
1.
|
Represents the grant date fair value of stock awards granted in 2014, 2013 and 2012 under the ICP. Values were determined in accordance with FASB ASC Topic 718 (Topic 718), and the assumptions made in calculating them can be found in Note 19 of the Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements in Item 8 of our 2014 Form 10-K. Stock awards granted in 2014 include grants of RSUs and PSAs, the latter of which are subject to performance conditions.
|
|
The table below shows the grant date fair value of the RSUs and PSAs, as well as the value of the PSAs assuming the maximum level of performance (200% of target) is achieved under both the ROE and TSR performance measures described on page 46. The grant date fair value for the PSAs was calculated in accordance with Topic 718 using a performance factor of 1.08, the probable outcome on the date of grant. The stock awards granted in 2014 are described in more detail in the Grants of Plan-Based Awards table on page 58.
|
NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICER
|
GRANT DATE
FAIR VALUE OF
2014 RSU
($)
|
GRANT DATE
FAIR VALUE OF
2014 PSA
($)
|
VALUE OF 2014
PSA AT MAXIMUM
PERFORMANCE LEVEL
($)
|
Dennis R. Glass
|
3,037,518
|
2,551,534
|
4,725,062
|
Randal J. Freitag
|
421,289
|
606,602
|
1,123,337
|
Charles C. Cornelio*
|
347,571
|
500,503
|
926,857
|
Wilford H. Fuller
|
353,765
|
509,440
|
943,408
|
Mark E. Konen
|
456,981
|
658,034
|
1,218,582
|
NAME
|
PERQUISITESa
($)
|
TAX GROSS-UPS
OR
MISCELLANEOUS
($)
|
401(K) MATCH, CORE AND TRANSITION CONTRIBUTIONSb
($)
|
ADDITIONAL COMPANY CONTRIBUTIONS INTO DEFERRED COMPENSATION
PLAN (SPECIAL EXECUTIVE CREDIT AND EXCESS MATCH, CORE AND TRANSITION CONTRIBUTIONS)c
($)
|
TOTAL
($)
|
|||||
Dennis R. Glass
|
47,156
|
__
|
34,500
|
766,498
|
848,154
|
|||||
Randal J. Freitag
|
12,700
|
__
|
32,760
|
212,681
|
258,141
|
|||||
Charles C. Cornelio
|
14,050
|
__
|
34,500
|
223,785
|
272,335
|
|||||
Wilford H. Fuller
|
__
|
__
|
26,000
|
339,026
|
365,026
|
|||||
Mark E. Konen
|
16,844
|